The following are characters created and/or played as PCs by Fenton.

Note that various characters began as PCs but eventually were turned into NPCs. This was generally because they either became too powerful to be used as a character in an ongoing campaign, because the time had come for them to be (semi-)retired, or because Fenton is rarely a player any more and therefore the characters became NPCs by default. On occasion, a character began as an NPC (typically the NPC child of a PC and an NPC) and when Fenton became a player in a friend's game, took over the character as a PC (with the GM's permission) because he liked the concept.

Characters that started as PCs but ended up becoming NPCs:

• Braxton Donahoe (WoD) - started as a PC in an ancilla-level WoD game (set in Ashford) ran by Dermont, and ended up becoming a Primogen and too powerful to use as an active PC. Was semi-retired and is now a key NPC in Fenton's Ashford by Night game, typically serving as plot instigator, patron or, on occasion, antagonist.
• Tatjana (WoD) - originally began as a neonate PC in Divineshadow's New York: by Night Sabbat WoD campaign, and somehow survived enough crap and committed diablerie enough times to become powerful, and infamous enough to be a good antagonist/antihero for Fenton's own Ashford by Night game.
• Laughs-at-Rage (WoD) - originally made for Elodan's Werewolf: the Apocalypse game. An outsider (a Nuwisha in a Garou game and sept), with more foolhardy courage than common sense, he miraculously made it to rank 4. At the end of the campaign, he was a fun and useful enough character to be brought into Fenton's Ashford by Night game as a comic-relief-but-dangerous NPC ally (he worked equally well in both the VtM and WtA sides of the setting). Although he eventually self-sacrificed to save the PCs of that campaign, it was revealed that he had a daughter named Giggles-at-Anger, who keeps his memory alive with her like-father-like-daughter madcappery.
• Nicole Llambert - originally an abomination (vampire werewolf) NPC for Divineshadow's Dark Alliance: Vancouver game, eventually reached a point that felt "right" to retire her from that game at the campaign's conclusion (Fenton took over using Alexa Schofield, see below) and imported her into his Ashford by Night campaign. She often serves as a mediator between the kindred (of which she was once one) and the Garou, as she has been a member of both, and knows that there is potential for good alliances if both sects can get over their traditional enmities (as she herself eventually did after her embrace).
• Antonio "Tony the Tiger" Bertoli (WoD) - began as a neonate PC for Elodan's 1920s Chicago by Night game (along with his brother Franco Bertoli, played by Dermont) and at the end of the campaign was brought into Fenton's Ashford by Night campaign (which was set chronologically 90 years later) as an Ancilla.
• Kaitene Ziçanlos - originally a PC during a Vampire: Dark Ages game run by a friend for a few months during his second year in university, of which it was just Fenton and his friend (who he introduced into roleplay, and was the GM for this game), Fenton ended up introducing him into his Ashford game as an NPC by having the current players discover and rescue Kaitene from Torpor (and Sabbat would-be diablerie), and help him adjust to the modern world after literal centuries of being in torpor. He is now a respected NPC elder and ally to the players.
• Sin (CoD original PC version)/Sin (WoD ported NPC version) - created for Darth Peachy's proposed Mage: the Awakening (Chronicles of Darkness) game - but when the game was cancelled decided he liked the character concept enough to port her over to use as a young Mage NPC in his Ashford by Night game. He has yet to actually introduce her, however, but plans to the next time they play WoD.

Characters that became PCs, but were originally created as NPCs:

• Alexa Schofield (WoD) - originally created by Fenton as the NPC daughter of Elodan and an NPC mage, had some tragedy growing up and when joining Divineshadow's Dark Alliance: Vancouver WoD game, got permission to use her as a PC as she was about the right power level for that game.
• Jenna "Selene" Gray (Galactica) - was originally created as a plucky NPC Raptor pilot and friend to the PC Viper pilots for a planned Battlestar Galactica game that never got off the ground. When Darth Peachy began his game, Fenton decided she'd be a fun character to use and she was transferred into his game with her history completely intact - she literally "missed the boat" and failed to get back to her Battlestar (Galactica) on time, and ended up on the Battlestar Hyperion instead.